Allysin Kay

Until March 2010, Kay worked exclusively for BCWA. Her first match for another promotion was facing Jefferson Saint for Beyond Wrestling. In mid-2010, she began wrestling for Main Event Championship Wrestling, debuting against Jessicka Havok. The duo entered a feud that spilled into other promotions, including Cleveland All-Pro Wrestling. The feud concluded in a two out of three falls anything goes street fight, won by Havok. Following that, Kay and Havok formed a tag team called Team Be Jealous.

Kay debuted in Absolute Intense Wrestling in April 2010, losing to Jessicka Havok, and the following month lost to Angel Dust. At Girls Night Out 3 in January 2011, she earned her first victory in AIW, defeating Roxie Cotton. In June at Road to Absolution, she joined the Flexor Industries faction. At Girls Night Out 4, she defeated Mickie Knuckles. She lost to Mia Yim at Girls Night Out 5, a match where Yim broke Kay's nose with a kick. At Girls Night Out 6 on April 15, 2012, Kay faced Yim for the vacant AIW Women's Championship, which Kay won. The third match of the series took place at Girls Night Out 7, where Kay retained her championship. In 2012, she defended against Jennifer Blake, Crazy Mary Dobson, and KC Warfield. In 2013, she retained against Mickie Knuckles at Girls Night Out 8, and successfully defended against Veda Scott and MsChif in October and November respectively. In March 2014, she retained against Leah Von Dutch at Girls Night Out 11, but lost the championship to Athena at Girls Night Out 12 on March 29 in a no disqualification, falls count anywhere match.

In January 2011, Kay debuted for Women Superstars Uncensored (WSU) at The Final Chapter internet pay-per-view in a loss to Jamilia Craft. She returned two months later, losing to Kristin Astara at the 4th Anniversary Show. At the Uncensored Rumble in June, she was on the losing end of an eight-person tag team match and also competed in the rumble. In August, she earned her first win in WSU in a four-way match against Marti Belle, Tina San Antonio, and Niya. Kay then joined forces with Jessicka Havok and Sassy Stephie, forming a stable known as The Midwest Militia. They won a War Games match against Team WSU at Breaking Barriers II in November. On March 3, 2012, Kay and Stephie won the WSU Tag Team Championship by defeating the Soul Sisters. They successfully defended against Alicia and Brittney Savage and the Soul Sisters in April.

As part of a talent exchange, The Midwest Militia began competing for NCW Femmes Fatales in 2012. At NCWFF's ninth show in July, they defeated Courtney Rush, Xandra Bale, and Cat Power in a six-woman tag team match. At WSU's Queen & King Tournament, they retained the championship against Marti Belle and Lexxus.

Kay joined Shine Wrestling in 2012, debuting on the inaugural show, forming a tag team with Taylor Made. The duo defeated Tracy Taylor and Su Yung. April Hunter was later added, with the trio calling themselves Made in Sin. After adding Rain and Ivelisse Velez, the stable became Valkyrie. At Shine 8, Valkyrie defeated Amazing Kong, Angelina Love, Christina Von Eerie, and Yim in an eight-woman tag team match. At Shine 10 in May 2013, Kay defeated Nikki Roxx in a qualifying match for the Shine Championship tournament. When she interfered in a main event, she was suspended for 90 days and removed from the tournament. She returned at Shine 13, teaming with Ivelisse to defeat Havok and Amazing Kong, but accidentally clotheslined Havok. On the following show, she attacked Havok, leading to a singles match at Shine 15, which ended in a no contest. After a double countout, they faced off in a Ybor City street fight in April 2014, which ended in a no contest when Havok was struck by a car as part of the storyline.

Kay made her Shimmer Women Athletes debut on October 27, 2012, as part of Volume 49. She and Taylor Made defeated Shazza McKenzie and Veda Scott. Made in Sin lost on Volume 51 to Regeneration X, and Volume 52 to Kana and LuFisto. At Volume 55, Kay defeated Thunderkitty. Made in Sin defeated MsEerie at Volume 56, but lost a six-woman tag match on Volume 57.

Kay debuted for Ring of Honor at a television taping on November 3, 2012, in a loss to MsChif.

On July 7, 2013, Kay started her first tour of Japan with the World Woman Pro-Wrestling Diana promotion, losing to Keiko Aono. On August 4, she and Crazy Mary unsuccessfully challenged for the WWWD World Tag Team Championship.